preferences

NSW2027 – How Optional Preferential Voting could Re-elect the Minns Government

At March’s South Australian election, One Nation polled 22.9% of the vote, relegating the Liberal Party on 18.9% to third place.

While a good result for One Nation, it had no impact on the landslide re-election of Premier Peter Malinauskas and his Labor government. The expectation that Labor would be re-elected may have even boosted One Nation by giving voters freedom to cast a protest vote.

November’s Victorian election will be very different. Against an unpopular third term Labor government, and with the Liberal/National Coalition failing to establish a clear lead in opinion polls, a vote for One Nation will have consequences for who forms government after the election.

Even if One Nation falls short of the balance of power, the party will have a critical presence in the Victorian upper house. A vote for One Nation in November could determine who governs Victoria, and a significant presence in both houses will see One Nation influence how a new (and presumably) Coalition government controls the levers of state.

Four months later in March 2027, New South Wales goes to the polls. As in South Australia, the election will see a first term Labor government seeking re-election. Polling indicates the Minns government remains broadly popular without scaling the heights of popularity achieved by SA Labor.

There have been reports that One Nation is more confident of its prospects in NSW than Victoria. That’s backed by past election results where One Nation consistently attracts stronger support in New South Wales compared to Victoria.

The Minns government fell short of a majority in 2023, but the government’s grip on office has never been threatened. Labor has good working relations with the large lower house crossbench populated by Greens and Independents. The government’s bigger hurdles have been in Legislative Council.

Based on the result of the Farrer Federal by-election in May, there is every chance the NSW election will see the National Party reduced to a rump.

One Nation will also be hoping to repeat its success against Labor at the recent WA Secret Harbour by-election. There is a strong chance One Nation will be Labor’s major opponent in the industrial areas of the Hunter Valley and Illawarra. One Nation will also challenge Labor in a string of outer Sydney seats.

The Liberal Party will be squeezed, possibly losing its remaining rural seats, and face further challenges from Independents in traditional Liberal heartland seats. As I discuss below, the Liberals will also struggle against Labor in a string of marginal Sydney seats.

Opinion polls have pointed to Labor having the highest state-wide primary vote with One Nation and the Coalition splitting the non-Labor vote.

Even if Labor’s vote is down compared to 2023, odds are Labor will still emerge from the election with the most lower house seats, perhaps even with a lower house majority.

There are two reasons why Labor must be favourite to win.

The first is that Labor’s vote is likely to be more effectively distributed to turn votes into seats. Labor polled 37.0% in 2023, broken down to 40.8% in greater Sydney to win 31 of 59 seats and 49.8% to win 10 of 12 seats in the Hunter and Illawarra. But Labor polled only 22.7% in rural and regional areas to win 4 of 22 seats.

Labor’s vote could slip to single digits across rural NSW, areas where Labor has little hope of gaining seats. But where Labor needs to win seats, on the coast from Port Stephens to Kiama, Labor is best placed to lead on first preferences.

The Liberal Party was fortunate to win as many greater Sydney seats as it did in 2023. The party goes into the 2027 election defending seven seats on margins under 2.3%, Ryde, Holsworthy, Oatley, Terrigal, Drummoyne, Winston Hills and Miranda. Any switch of Liberal support to One Nation in these seats will leave Labor with the highest primary vote and well placed to win.

Which is where the second reason Labor is favoured to win comes into play.

That is Optional Preferential Voting (OPV). At Federal elections, and elections in other mainland states, voters are required to complete a full sequence of ballot paper preferences. In NSW they are not. Preferences beyond a ‘1’ vote are optional.

In this post I’ll explain why OPV will favour Labor. I also explain why under OPV it is critical for the Coalition and One Nation to reciprocate on preferences. To not recommend preferences would split the non-Labor vote and increase the number of exhausted preferences.
Read More »NSW2027 – How Optional Preferential Voting could Re-elect the Minns Government

The Impact on Senate Election Results of Abolishing GVTs – the Lessons for Victoria

Over the next week I will publish several posts looking at the abolition of Group Voting Tickets (GVTs) in Victoria and the implications this has for the state’s Legislative Council election in November.

Work I’ve undertaken in the past, about Senate elections both before and after the abolition of GVTs, produces clear conclusions.

Abolishing GVTs will increase the importance of first preference votes and diminish the value of preference transfers. Abolishing GVTs advantages parties that campaign for votes and disadvantages those that rely on deals and transfers to be elected.

Abolishing GVTs also ends the ability of parties to conspire and use GVTs to block the election of high polling parties. It also stops parties using GVTs to elect low-polling parties that few voters have heard of into important upper house balance of power seats.

The key aim of abolishing GVTs is to end party control over between-party preferences and leave it to voters to make the decision. With 95% of votes tied up in party tickets, too many elections had been decided by opaque preferences deals that voters had little knowledge of. A new form of above-the-line (ATL) voting was created allowing voters to show preferences for parties rather than candidates. Voters still had the option to vote below-the-line (BTL) for individual candidates of any party.

In other states this has been implemented with full optional preferential voting. A voter must indicate a first preference for a formal vote, but further preferences were optional. At elections conducted under the new rules, only a third of ATL ballot papers have preferences beyond ‘1’ and exhausted preferences have come to play a part in deciding who wins the final seats. (See my previous post that covered experience with the change in NSW.)

By contrast, the Senate instructions after the abolition of GVTs has been to mark at least six preferences, though a savings provision allows any first preference vote to remain formal. Under these instructions, around 95% of ballot papers are completed above the line (ATL) with between-party preferences. Given the exhaustion rate of preferences for minor party votes, there hasn’t been much difference between the role of preferences in the two ballot marking systems.

Abolishing GVTs makes it nearly impossible to win from a low vote AND from behind on preferences. Abolishing GVTs does not prevent a party winning from a low vote, nor prevent a trailing candidate from winning on preferences, though it does make it harder. But is becomes extremely difficult to do both at the same time.

A party winning from a low vote is possible without GVTs if there is an even split of vote between remaining parties. The United Australia Party’s Ralph Babet won a Victorian Senate seat in 2022 from only 0.28 quotas (4.0%). This was because there were five parties between 0.20 and 0.28 quotas competing for one seat. Without GVTs, preference flows were relatively weak and Babet maintained his lead to win the final seat. Preferences were not responsible for his victory.

And coming from behind is possible. In NSW at the 2025 Federal election, strong preference flows from the Coalition and small right-wing parties allowed One Nation on 0.42 quotas (6.1%) to pass Labor’s third candidate on 0.63 quotas (9.1%).

Without GVTs, the classic 2013 Victorian Senate case of Ricky Muir (Australian Motoring Enthusiasts Party) on 0.5% defeating Helen Kroger (Liberal) on 11.6% would be impossible. Muir’s election was the equivalent of a lower house candidate on 1.7% defeating a candidate with 40%.

As One Nation showed in 2025, is is possible for a candidate with two-thirds of another candidate’s vote to come from behind and win on preference transfers. Voters still have their say on preferences, but without GVTs, results can’t be engineered. Muir’s case of winning from behind with only one-23rd of the winning candidate’s vote is absolutely impossible without GVTs.

And to date, every jurisdiction except except Victoria has understood this inherent problem with GVTs and abolished them. Next week it appears Victoria will be the last to join the club.

Based on One Nation’s two come from behind Senate victories in 2025, I think around 0.4 quotas is the minimum a party needs for victory, 6.5% translated into Victorian Legislative Council numbers. That’s unless you get a case like Ralph Babet’s where a seat remains to be filled and all remaining parties have a low vote.

Looking at how many parties have been elected from trailing positions, the difference produced by the abolition of GVTs for Senate elections is clear.

At the 2013 half-Senate election, the last to use GVTs, 9 of the 36 state Senate positions were won by trailing candidates. At three half-Senate elections since the abolition of GVTs, only 2 of 108 state Senate seats have been won by trailing candidates.

And both of those trailing wins were aided by Senate instructions to mark 6 preferences. Trailing wins may be even harder under instructions for ‘1’ with further preferences optional.
Read More »The Impact on Senate Election Results of Abolishing GVTs – the Lessons for Victoria

The Financial Review’s Inaccurate Preference Analysis

One Nation’s polling surge has triggered an intense dissection of recent election results.

One Nation made the final preference count at the recent Farrer by-election. One Nation also finished in the final preference pairing in more than half of South Australian electorates at the state election in March. These results offer a mine of data where One Nation is a recipient of preferences rather than a provider.

Trying its luck dissecting the results on 7 June was the Australian Financial Review. It published an analysis piece on Farrer and South Australia headlined “How One Nation is winning the preferences war (with the Greens’ help)”.

As I will outline in this post, the article has confused published preference distribution data with more accurate but unavailable preference flow data. And the remark about Greens preferences isn’t backed by my analysis of the data.

The article was published three days before the Farrer flow data was released and the South Australian analysis has been attributed to preference flow data that is not available.

With the South Australian results, the article uses preference transfer data to draw some odd conclusions about Green preferences, and illustrates flows for other parties that aren’t justified given the quality of the data.

That the analytical problems, which I’ll explain in this post, have passed without much comment from anyone is due to the published chart included below. The chart tries to show SA preference flows from other parties to One Nation.

The chart’s meaning and data source are hard to unravel, but mirth has been the main reaction due to the inclusion of imaginary party names. It has caused the AFR to publish a correction and remove the chart from the on-line article.

LCP, an acronym for the Legalise Cannabis Party, is rendered as the Liberal Catholic Party. FGA, for Sarah Game’s Fair Go Australia, is transformed into the Family Guardian Association.

To the best of my knowledge, neither party name has ever been used in Australia.

It looks to me like a case of AI ‘hallucination’, AI asked to convert codes into party names and guessing it wrong. I doubt a human made those errors.

But enough cheap shots over party names. What I really want to explain is the article’s problems with data source and analysis.

With Farrer, I want to explain how the chart used to demonstrate the composition of One Nation’s winning vote uses the wrong data. It results in an incorrect emphasis on whose preferences were responsible for One Nation’s final margin.

With South Australia, the available data cannot be used to isolate the preference flows shown in the now deleted AFR chart. And the data that is available does not support the headlined conclusions about Greens preferences.

In both cases the problem comes down to limitations on how you can use preference transfer data from published distributions. The data must be treated with caution and can’t be automatically compared with more accurate preference flow data.Read More »The Financial Review’s Inaccurate Preference Analysis

Updates on the South Australian Election Result

(UPDATE: This was written on Sunday to try and explain how the count would unfold after election night. After a few days rest and recovery, I’ve started another post with rolling updates of the result which I will update at least once each day. For more regular updates I suggest you use the ABC election site which will update results every time the Electoral Commission produces new data. I’m doing work on the site weeding out inconsistencies in the Electoral Commission’s data.)

I’ve been in Adelaide this week working for the ABC on the state election coverage. I may have retired from on camera work, but I’m still involved in analysis off camera.

And last night was one of the most challenging coverages I’ve worked on. I estimate that half of the state’s 47 electorates had a choice of preferences that did not reflect the primary results that arrived on election night. One Nation finished in the top two in around half of the state’s seats. This was very many more seats than the Electoral Commission had prepared for.

That’s not a criticism of the Electoral Commission. It must nominate a pairing of candidate before the count is known, and is guided by history as much if not more than by opinion polls.

But that’s all about last night. Let me describe how the count will unfold from here.
Read More »Updates on the South Australian Election Result

Do Green Voters Follow How-to-Votes?

Headline Summary – Strong flows of Green preferences to Labor are often cited as being due to preference “deals”. When you examine the data, the flows are due to the instinctive inclination of Green voters to put Labor second. Even in seats where the Greens recommend preferences to other candidates before Labor, many Green voters still preference Labor. It’s how Labor narrowly defeated Independent challengers in Fremantle (WA) and Bean (ACT) at the 2025 election.

One of the legacies of Senate group voting tickets (GVTs) is that political observers continue to talk about preferences as “deals”. Show and tell preference meetings and parties registering preference tickets at the same time were all part of Senate deal making with GVTs. And those deals stuck as GVTs could deliver preference flows above 90% by taking control of a voter’s ballot paper.

The GVT system was rightly abolished in 2016, ending deals that guaranteed preference flows. The Senate is now like the House where parties can only recommend preference, not direct them. With the exception of one brief experiment in Western Australia (see my previous post on the subject), lower house preferences have always been about recommendation rather than control.

What might be termed a “deal” is no more than agreement on printing preference recommendations. This can occur without an agreement as parties often have mutual self-interest in recommendations. For obvious ideological reasons, parties and candidates tend to recommend preferences within left or right blocks rather then recommend preferences across the political divide.

And whatever negotiations do occur, they have no impact unless most voters receive a party’s how-to-vote, and that voters choose to follow the recommendation. Voters can have their own views on where the preferences of their vote should flow, whatever is on a how-to-vote.

Many voters never see the how-to-vote of their first choice party, especially with minor parties. Without seeing a how-to-vote, a voter’s preferences can only match a how-to-vote by guesswork. Follow rates are always higher with fewer candidates on a ballot paper and when a how-to-vote recommendation follows an understood ideological order.

There are discussions between party representatives about preferences. But even without “deals”, it still makes sense for Labor and the Greens to recommend preferences for each other before parties of the right. It still makes sense for the Coalition and small right-of-centre parties to recommend preferences for each other before the left.

With the Coalition always attacking Labor for working with “radical left-wing Greens”, it also makes sense for the Coalition to recommend preferences for Labor before the Greens. That said, the Coalition has at times been flexible on whether to preference Labor or the Greens.

So what about the Coalition and One Nation? That may be a current hot topic, but it’s not the purpose of this post. All I’ll say for now is that strategy, tactics and practice on Coalition-One Nation preferences have changed depending on political circumstances.

This post looks at data on whether voters follow Green preference recommendations. At the 2025 Federal election, 88% of Greens preferences flowed to Labor before the Coalition. For the past 15 years, the percentage flow of Green preferences to Labor has drifted higher as shown in the chart below.

Increased candidate numbers may have removed some “random” Green votes cast as an objection to the major parties. I believe Coalition attacks on the Greens may have led to a decline in conservative voters giving a first preference to the Greens. Not being Greens helps explain why ‘teal’ Independents have had success attracting former Liberal voters.

The last time the Greens issued open how-to-votes without a recommendation to Labor was in 2010. It made little difference to the flow of preferences to Labor as I wrote about in 2011.

What about if the Greens recommended preferences for the Coalition ahead of Labor? Unfortunately data is very thin on the ground, down to a single case, the 2020 Johnston by-election for a seat in the NT Parliament. Even that was a preference throw between Labor and the short-lived Territory Alliance rather than the Country Liberal Party and was due to NT Labor policy on fracking. Preferences flows were much weaker but still 56% to Labor.

But the Greens putting Labor ahead of the Coalition does not mean Labor is placed second. As I will discuss in this post, there were several examples at the 2025 election which show that strong preference flows from Green candidates is not just a matter of voters following a how-to-vote.

If you look at Coalition-Independent contests, Green preference flows match those seen in Labor-Coalition contests. But the path by which Green preferences reached Independents was not a simple case of following a how-to-vote. And the situation is even more revealing in Labor-Independent contests with Labor retaining two seats in 2025 due to Greens voters making up their own minds on preferences.
Read More »Do Green Voters Follow How-to-Votes?

SA2026 – One Nation polling and its prospects of winning seats

The last few weeks have seen an opinion poll surge in support for One Nation at the expense of the Liberal Party.

Clearly opinion polls are measuring a real political phenomena with dramatic shifts in support on the right of Australian politics.

The question is, are the polling numbers reporting actual voting intentions, or is it just measuring between election disenchantment with the current course of politics?

We may be about to find an answer to this question with something better than an opinion poll – an actual election in South Australia on 21 March.

The working assumption for most of the last four years has been that the Labor government, led by popular Premier Peter Malinauskas, will be easily re-elected. Labor won 27 of 47 seats in 2022, has gained two more seats at by-elections since, and opinion polls have consistently shown Labor’s support higher than at the last election.

Which means that the story attracting most attention on 21 March might be the fate of the Liberal Opposition, and what a dreadful result means for the Federal Coalition.

The Liberal Party’s dreadful result in South Australia at last May’s Federal election, wiped out in all metropolitan seats, could portend an even worse fate at the state election. Recent polling has the Liberal primary vote collapsing and a surge in One Nation support. (See my previous post of the 2025 Federal result in South Australia.)

In this post I run through detail on how One Nation performed in South Australian federal seats in 2025, and in the Senate. I also look at the party’s performance in state seats at the 2022 election, including voting for the Legislative Council.

(See my previous post on the 2022 South Australian election which includes link to my publication summarising the result in both houses and including detailed analysis of lower house preference flows.)

In this post I also analyse One Nation preference flows at the 2025 Federal and 2022 state election. In complex three and four candidate contests, the order of candidate exclusion and complex preference flows could be critical.

I then run through some of the key contests at the election. In short polling says Labor will retain all its own seats and most likely make gains at the Liberal Party’s expense, possibly winning every seat in the Adelaide metropolitan area.

Which leaves how the contest will unfold in rural South Australia. Polling shows One Nation support surging at the expense of the Liberal Party and Independents. I have my suspicions that state-wide polling based on party vote overlooks that most regional SA seats will be contested by popular Independent members and candidates. I suspect some of the reported One Nation support will in fact be swept up by Independents.

Which is not to say the SA election on 21 March will prove the polls right or wrong. The polls are measuring disenchantment with politics, but perhaps are not capable of isolating the candidates that will benefit from a shifting voter mood.

For all the talk of whether there will by a preference arrangement, formal or otherwise, between Liberal and One Nation and against Labor, the presence of Independents creates more than simple binary preference contests. Options for voters to preference Independents ahead of the major parties and One Nation complicates the picture in regional seats and makes order of exclusion for preferences a complicating factor in turning party vote shares into elected members. Read More »SA2026 – One Nation polling and its prospects of winning seats

FED2025 – Independent Two-Party Preferred Preference Flow Data

The 2025 House of Representatives election was the first where more than a third of primary votes were cast for ‘Others’.

In total, minor parties and Independents recorded 33.6% of the primary vote. This was more than 31.8% for the Coalition and only one percent short of Labor’s vote.

The rise in support for ‘Others’ has changed the nature of seat contests at House elections. Elections today are far removed from the days when almost all seats finished as two-party preferred contests between Labor and the Coalition.

The word ‘classic’, which I’ve always associated with vintage cars and ice cream marketing, has been adopted by the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) to describe traditional Labor versus Coalition contests. Or rather the AEC calls all other combinations of final candidates after preferences as ‘Non-Classic’, which it helpfully provides a list of on its election results website. (2025 list here)

In this post I’m providing information on two-party preferred preference flows in these Non-Classic seats, data that has not previously been available. This includes preference flow splits between Labor and the Coalition from votes cast for Independents in Non-Classic contests.

Until 1983, preferences were only distributed in seats where no candidate reached 50% of the primary vote. The AEC began to conduct distributions in all seats for ‘information purposes’ in 1984. That election saw every seat finish as a two-party preferred race.

Every election since has seen at least one Non-Classic contest. And as the chart below shows, the numbers have ballooned at the last four elections.

The chart above is based on all Non-Classic contests. The last three elections have seen a particular surge in these contests involving Independents. In 2019 there were seven final counts that involved Independents, rising to 16 in 2022 and 20 in 2025.

The AEC continues to do full distributions of preferences to the final pairing of candidates in every seat. Since the 1990s it has also undertaken alternative two-party preferred counts in every seat. (Except in Bradfield in 2025 for reasons explained later.)

The AEC counts preferences in two ways. First is by conducting the legally required full distribution of preferences in every seat to produce a two-candidate preferred count. Second, the AEC tallies what are called ‘preference flows’ in every seat for both two-candidate and two-party preferred finishes. I’ll describe how preference flows are calculated inside the post.Read More »FED2025 – Independent Two-Party Preferred Preference Flow Data

The Success of Local Independents – Kooyong

A key story of the last three federal elections has been the Liberal Party’s loss of once safe heartland seats to ‘teal’ Independents.

The list is a catalogue of seats once held by Prime Ministers and senior Liberal Ministers. In NSW there’s Wentworth, North Sydney (now abolished), Warringah, Mackellar and Bradfield. In Victoria it’s Goldstein (recovered in 2025) and Kooyong, and in Western Australia, Curtin.

These electorates top lists of the most affluent in the country. They encompass some of the most desirable and expensive real estate in each state. As recently as a decade ago, it was unthinkable they could leave the Liberal fold.

There are no Queensland or South Australian seats in the above list, but two could be. The Adelaide Hills seat of Mayo, held by Rebekha Sharkie since 2016, is effectively an independent as the only member of the Centre Alliance. Ryan, Brisbane’s leafiest and once safest Liberal seat, has been held by the Greens since 2022.

As well as being Liberal Party losses, these seats have seen a dramatic decline in their Liberal two-party preferred margins based on alternative preference counts versus Labor.

Indeed, Wentworth, Warringah, Ryan and Mayo recorded Labor two-party preferred majorities by alternative counts in 2025. Had a full two-party preferred count been completed in Bradfield, this once safest of safe Liberal seats could also have turned red.

The paradox is that Labor is achieving record two-party preferred results in these seats despite the party’s primary vote collapsing. The decline in Liberal two-party preferred results in these seats says more about Liberal support in its once safe seats than it says about Labor prospects.

Support for both sides of politics has declined since the high point of two-party politics in 1975. The decline has accelerated in the last two decades. Labor’s support is down sharply from its 2007 victory under Kevin Rudd. The Coalition’s collapse is an even steeper decline from a higher starting point at the 2013 election.

The loss for Labor has been in large part matched by rising support for the Greens. Much of Labor’s fall has also been in seats it doesn’t win, such as rural seats and Coalition seats contested by high profile Independents. This causes Labor’s loss of primary vote to have less impact on the number of seats it wins.

For the Coalition, and more particularly the Liberal Party, the destination of lost primary votes is less obvious. The Liberal Party has lost some support to Labor and to several conservative minor parties. But it is the loss of support in a limited number of seats to ‘teal’ and other centrist Independents that has damaged the Liberal Party by costing it once safe seats.

In this post I’m going to look at the loss of Liberal vote to the centre, to urban Independents. To illustrate the trend, I’m going to analyse one ‘teal’ seat in depth, the inner Melbourne seat of Kooyong.
Read More »The Success of Local Independents – Kooyong

One Nation’s Poll Surge – the first 25 seats to watch

With One Nation surging in the polls, the obvious question is – which seats can the party win.

The first cabs off the rank would be the seats where One Nation polled strongest in 2025.

There were only two seats where One Nation reached the final pairing of candidates after preferences, the Labor seat of Hunter in NSW, and Maranoa in Queensland held by National Party Leader David Littleproud.

In both seats the One Nation candidate finished third on first preferences but reached second place through preferences flowing from other right-of-centre parties. These included Family First, Trumpet of Patriots, Libertarians, Shooters Fishers and Farmers and Gerard Rennick’s People First.

Including Hunter and Maranoa, there were 26 seats overall where One Nation was one of the final three candidates during the distribution of preferences. This point of the count is commonly called the three-candidate preferred count (3CP).

Of these, 25 were Labor-Coalition-One Nation contests. A 26th seat was Indi, held by Independent Helen Haines. I’ve left Indi out of the analysis that follows as I would expect Haines to do well with preference flows from all other candidates in a contest versus One Nation.

There are many other seats beyond these 25 where One Nation’s poll surge will put the party into the three-candidate count. And some of these may be more winnable than those I list inside the post. In some of the seats I list, Burt being a good example, it may not be possible for One Nation to win given how strong Labor’s primary vote was in 2025.

Of the 25 seats I list, 12 are in Queensland, six in New South Wales, three in Victoria, two in WA and one each in South Australia and Tasmania.

Splitting the LNP into Liberal and National holdings, 12 of the seats are National held, seven Liberal held, and six held by Labor.

Two-thirds of the seats are outside the capital cities, the rest generally in outer parts of capitals.

The table is inside the post.
Read More »One Nation’s Poll Surge – the first 25 seats to watch

Statistics on Preference Flows between the Coalition and One Nation

This post is additional information on preference flows related to a post I published earlier today, “Liberal, National and One Nation – Friends, Enemies or Frenemies?”

With One Nation’s surge in support in recent polls, pollsters and election modelers have been looking around for information on preferences. Especially for examples of how Coalition preferences might flow when excluded in contests between Labor and One Nation.

I’ve managed to pull as much information as I can from recent Federal and Queensland elections. I hope you find it useful.Read More »Statistics on Preference Flows between the Coalition and One Nation