At March’s South Australian election, One Nation polled 22.9% of the vote, relegating the Liberal Party on 18.9% to third place.
While a good result for One Nation, it had no impact on the landslide re-election of Premier Peter Malinauskas and his Labor government. The expectation that Labor would be re-elected may have even boosted One Nation by giving voters freedom to cast a protest vote.
November’s Victorian election will be very different. Against an unpopular third term Labor government, and with the Liberal/National Coalition failing to establish a clear lead in opinion polls, a vote for One Nation will have consequences for who forms government after the election.
Even if One Nation falls short of the balance of power, the party will have a critical presence in the Victorian upper house. A vote for One Nation in November could determine who governs Victoria, and a significant presence in both houses will see One Nation influence how a new (and presumably) Coalition government controls the levers of state.
Four months later in March 2027, New South Wales goes to the polls. As in South Australia, the election will see a first term Labor government seeking re-election. Polling indicates the Minns government remains broadly popular without scaling the heights of popularity achieved by SA Labor.
There have been reports that One Nation is more confident of its prospects in NSW than Victoria. That’s backed by past election results where One Nation consistently attracts stronger support in New South Wales compared to Victoria.
The Minns government fell short of a majority in 2023, but the government’s grip on office has never been threatened. Labor has good working relations with the large lower house crossbench populated by Greens and Independents. The government’s bigger hurdles have been in Legislative Council.
Based on the result of the Farrer Federal by-election in May, there is every chance the NSW election will see the National Party reduced to a rump.
One Nation will also be hoping to repeat its success against Labor at the recent WA Secret Harbour by-election. There is a strong chance One Nation will be Labor’s major opponent in the industrial areas of the Hunter Valley and Illawarra. One Nation will also challenge Labor in a string of outer Sydney seats.
The Liberal Party will be squeezed, possibly losing its remaining rural seats, and face further challenges from Independents in traditional Liberal heartland seats. As I discuss below, the Liberals will also struggle against Labor in a string of marginal Sydney seats.
Opinion polls have pointed to Labor having the highest state-wide primary vote with One Nation and the Coalition splitting the non-Labor vote.
Even if Labor’s vote is down compared to 2023, odds are Labor will still emerge from the election with the most lower house seats, perhaps even with a lower house majority.
There are two reasons why Labor must be favourite to win.
The first is that Labor’s vote is likely to be more effectively distributed to turn votes into seats. Labor polled 37.0% in 2023, broken down to 40.8% in greater Sydney to win 31 of 59 seats and 49.8% to win 10 of 12 seats in the Hunter and Illawarra. But Labor polled only 22.7% in rural and regional areas to win 4 of 22 seats.
Labor’s vote could slip to single digits across rural NSW, areas where Labor has little hope of gaining seats. But where Labor needs to win seats, on the coast from Port Stephens to Kiama, Labor is best placed to lead on first preferences.
The Liberal Party was fortunate to win as many greater Sydney seats as it did in 2023. The party goes into the 2027 election defending seven seats on margins under 2.3%, Ryde, Holsworthy, Oatley, Terrigal, Drummoyne, Winston Hills and Miranda. Any switch of Liberal support to One Nation in these seats will leave Labor with the highest primary vote and well placed to win.
Which is where the second reason Labor is favoured to win comes into play.
That is Optional Preferential Voting (OPV). At Federal elections, and elections in other mainland states, voters are required to complete a full sequence of ballot paper preferences. In NSW they are not. Preferences beyond a ‘1’ vote are optional.
In this post I’ll explain why OPV will favour Labor. I also explain why under OPV it is critical for the Coalition and One Nation to reciprocate on preferences. To not recommend preferences would split the non-Labor vote and increase the number of exhausted preferences.
Read More »NSW2027 – How Optional Preferential Voting could Re-elect the Minns Government